In distributed design processes, individual design subsystems have local control over design variables and seek to satisfy their own individual objectives, which may also be influenced by some system level objectives. The resulting network of coupled subsystems will either converge to a stable equilibrium or diverge in an unstable manner. In this paper, we study the dependence of system stability on the solution process architecture. The solution process architecture describes how the design subsystems are ordered and can be either sequential, parallel, or a hybrid that incorporates both parallel and sequential elements. In this paper, we demonstrate that the stability of a distributed design system does indeed depend on the solution process architecture chosen, and we create a general process architecture model based on linear systems theory. The model allows the stability of equilibrium solutions to be analyzed for distributed design systems by converting any process architecture into an equivalent parallel representation. Moreover, we show that this approach can accurately predict when the equilibrium is unstable and the system divergent when previous models suggest that the system is convergent.
Issue Section:
Research Papers
References
1.
Greising
, D.
, and Johnsson
, J.
, “Behind Boeing’s 787 Delays
,” Chicago Tribune
, Chicago, IL, December 10, 2007.2.
Yu
, R.
, 2008, “Boeing Again Delays Dreamliner’s Debut
,” U.S.A. Today
, Mclean, VA, January 16, 2008.3.
Gates
, D.
, 2009, “Strike, Supplier Problems Cause Boeing to Deliver 100 Fewer Jets Last Year Than Expected
,” Seattle Times
, Seattle, WA, January 9, 2009.4.
Wheelright
, S. C.
, and Clark
, K. B.
, 1992, Revolutionizing Product Development, Quantum Leaps in Speed, Efficiency, and Quality
, The Free
, NY
.5.
Sobieszczanski-Sobieski
, J.
, and Haftka
, R. T.
, 1997, “Multidisciplinary Aerospace Design Optimization: Survey of Recent Developments
,” Struct. Multidiscip. Optim.
, 14
(1
), pp. 1
–23
.6.
Khajavirad
, A.
, and Michalek
, J.
, 2008, “A Deterministic Lagrangian-Based Global Optimization Approach for Quasiseparable Nonconvex Mixed-Integer Nonlinear Programs
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 131
, p. 051009
.7.
Cramer
, E. J.
, Dennis
, J. E.
, Frank
, P. D.
, Lewis
, R. M.
, and Shubin
, G. R.
, 1994, “Problem Formulation for Multidisciplinary Optimization
,” SIAM J. Optim.
, 4
(4
), pp. 754
–776
.8.
Pahl
, G.
, and Beitz
, W.
, 1996, Engineering Design: A Systematic Approach
, Springer
, New York
.9.
Pugh
, S.
, 1996, Creating Innovative Products Using Total Design
, Addison-Wesley
, Reading, MA
.10.
Suh
, N. P.
, 2001, Axiomatic Design: Advances and Applications
, Oxford University
, New York
.11.
Wiecek
, M. M.
, and Reneke
, J. A.
, 2005, “Complex Systems Decomposition Under Uncertainty and Risk
,” 6th World Congress of Structural and Multidisciplinary Optimaztion
, Rio de Janeiro, May 30–June 3.12.
Kim
, H. M.
, Michelena
, N. F.
, Papalambros
, P. Y.
, and Jang
, T.
, 2003, “Target Cascading in Optimal System Design
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 125
(4
), pp. 474
–481
.13.
Wujek
, B.
, Renaud
, J. E.
, and Batill
, S.
, 1997, “A Concurrent Engineering Approach for Multidisciplinary Design in a Distributed Computing Environment
,” Multidisciplinary Design Optimization: State of the Art
, Hampton, VA, March 13–16, 1997.14.
Wujek
, B. A.
, Renaud
, J. E.
, Batill
, S. M.
, and Brockman
, J. B.
, 1996, “Concurrent Subspace Optimization Using Design Variable Sharing in a Distributed Computing Environment
,” Concurr. Eng. Res. Appl.
, 4
(4
), pp. 361
–377
.15.
Sobieszczanski-Sobieski
, J.
, Agte
, J. S.
, and Sandusky
, R. R.
, 1998, “Bi-Level Integrated System Synthesis (BLISS)
,” NASA Technical Memorandum—208715
, Hampton, VA.16.
Braun
, R. D.
, and Kroo
, I. M.
, 1996, “Development and Application of the Collaborative Optimization Architecture in a Multidisciplinary Design Environment
,” Multidisciplinary Design Optimization: State of the Art
, N.
Alexandrov
and M. Y.
Hussaini
, eds., SIAM
, Philadelphia, PA
.17.
Michalek
, J. J.
, Feinberg
, F. M.
, and Papalambros
, P. Y.
, 2004, “An Optimal Marketing and Engineering Design Model for Product Development Using Analytical Target Cascading
,” Tools and Methods of Competitive Engineering
, Mill
, Lausanne, CH
.18.
Chanron
, V.
, and Lewis
, K.
, 2006, “A Study of Convergence in Decentralized Design Processes
,” Res. Eng. Des.
, 16
(3
), pp. 133
–145
.19.
Vincent
, T. L.
, 1983, “Game Theory as a Design Tool
,” ASME J. Mech., Transm., Autom. Des.
, 105
(June
), pp. 165
–170
.20.
Lewis
, K.
, and Mistree
, F.
, 1997, “Collaborative, Sequential and Isolated Decisions in Design
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 120
(4
), pp. 643
–652
.21.
Loch
, C.
, Mihm
, J.
, and Huchzermeier
, A.
, 2003, “Concurrent Engineering and Design Oscillations in Complex Engineering Projects
,” Concurr. Eng. Res. Appl.
, 11
(3
), pp. 187
–199
.22.
Whitfield
, R. I.
, Duffy
, A. H. B.
, Coates
, G.
, and Hills
, W.
, 2002, “Distributed Design Coordination
,” Res. Eng. Des.
, 13
(4
), pp. 243
–253
.23.
Cho
, S.-H.
, and Eppinger
, S.
, 2005, “A Simulation-Based Process Model for Managing Complex Design Projects
,” IEEE Trans. Eng. Manage
., 52
(3
), pp. 316
–328
.24.
Browning
, T.
, and Eppinger
, S.
, 2002, “Modeling Impact of Process Architecture on Cost and Schedule Risk in Product Development
,” IEEE Trans. Eng. Manage
., 49
(4
), pp. 428
–442
.25.
Devendorf
, E.
, and Lewis
, K.
, 2009, “Are We There Yet? Investigating the Role of Design Process Architecture on Convergence Rate
,” ASME Design Engineering Technical Conferences
, San Diego, CA
, DETC2009-87517.26.
Devendorf
, E.
, and Lewis
, K.
, 2010, “Examining Interactions Between Solution Architecture and Designer Mistakes
,” ASME Design Engineering Technical Conferences
, Montreal, Canada
, DETC2010-28872.27.
McComb
, S. A.
, Green
, S. G.
, and Compton
, W. D.
, 1999, “Project Goals, Team Performance and Shared Understanding
,” J. Eng. Manage.
, 11
(3
), pp. 7
–12
.28.
Dong
, A.
, Hill
, A. W.
, and Agogino
, A. M.
, 2004, “A Document Analysis Method for Characterizing Design Team Performance
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 126
(3
), pp. 378
–385
.29.
Fu
, K.
, Cagan
, J.
, and Kotovsky
, K.
, 2010, “Design Team Convergence: The Influence of Example Solution Quality
,” ASME J. Mech. Des
., 132
(11
), 111005
.30.
Takai
, S.
, 2010, “A Game-Theoretic Model of Collaboration in Engineering Design
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 132
(5
), 051005
-1
.31.
32.
Thompson
, G. L.
, 1953, “Contributions to the Theory of Games
,” Signaling Strategies in N-Person Games
, Princeton University
, Princeton, NJ
.33.
Martson
, M.
, and Mistree
, F.
, 2000, “Game-Based Design: A Game Theoretic Extension to Decision-Based Design
,” ASME Design Engineering Technical Conferences
, Baltimore, MD
, DETC2000-DTM14578.34.
Hernandez
, G.
, Seepersad
, C. C.
, and Mistree
, F.
, 2002, “Designing for Maintenance: A Game Theoretic Approach
,” Eng. Optimiz.
, 34
(6
), pp. 561
–577
.35.
Lewis
, K.
, and Mistree
, F.
, 2001, “Modeling Subsystem Interactions: A Game Theoretic Approach
,” J. Des. Manuf. Autom.
, 1
(1
), pp. 17
–36
.36.
Chanron
, V.
, and Lewis
, K.
, 2004, “Convergence and Stability in Distributed Design of Large Systems
,” ASME Design Engineering Technical Conferences
, Montreal, Canada
, DETC2004-57344.37.
Chanron
, V.
, Singh
, T.
, and Lewis
, K.
, 2005, “Equilibrium Stability in Decentralized Design Systems
,” Int. J. Syst. Sci.
, 36
(10
), pp. 651
–662
.38.
Gopalakrishnan
, J.
, Singh
, T.
, and Lewis
, K.
, 2006, “Enhanced Convergence in Distributed Design Processes
,” ASME International Design Technical Conferences
, Philadelphia, PA
, DETC2006-99544.39.
Smith
, R. P.
, and Eppinger
, S. D.
, 1997, “Identifying Controlling Features of Engineering Design
,” Manage. Sci.
, 43
(3
), pp. 176
–193
.40.
Gurnani
, A.
, and Lewis
, K.
, 2008, “Collaborative, Decentralized Engineering Design at the Edge of Rationality
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 130
, p. 121101
.41.
Eppinger
, S. D.
, and Ulrich
, K. T.
, 2008, Product Design and Development
, McGraw Hill
, New York
.42.
Devendorf
, E.
, and Lewis
, K.
, 2008, “Planning on Mistakes: An Approach to Incorporate Error Checking into the Design Process
,” ASME Design Engineering Technical Conferences
, New York
, DETC2008-50006.43.
Poole
, D.
, 2011, Linear Algebra: A Modern Introduction
, 3rd ed., Cengage Learning
, Florence, KY
.44.
Ogata
, K.
, 1995, Discrete-Time Control Systems
, Prentice-Hall
, Upper Saddle River, NJ
.45.
Bretthorst
, G. L.
, 2008, “Nonuniform Sampling: Bandwidth and Aliasing
,” Concepts Magn. Reson.
, 32A
(6
), pp. 417
–435
.46.
Nathan
, A.
, 1976, “On Sampling a Function and Its Derivatives
,” Inf. Control
, 22
(2
), pp. 172
–182
.Copyright © 2011
by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
